UDC 378 Nataliya LUSHNIKOVA,
National University of Water Management
& Nature Recourses Use,
Praveen Kumar CHINTAKAYALA,
MBAF, Executive Director,
Kanth Enterprises, Mumbai, India
MBA, Aircraft maintenance supervisor,
United Airlines, Orlando, Fl. U.S
MASSIVE OPEN ONLINE COURSES FROM IVY LEAGUE UNIVERSITIES:
BENEFITS AND CHALLENGES FOR STUDENTS AND EDUCATORS
В статті розлянуто новий напрям електронного навчання - масові відкриті онлайн-курси, розроблені університетати Ліги плюща та іншими елітними університетами з усього світу. Оскільки ці курси є безкоштовними, мова йде про революційні зміни у системі вищої освіти на глобальному рівні. Поряд із низкою переваг, такий спосіб навчання створює певні складності як студентів, так і викладачів.
Ключові слова: електроне навчання, масовий відкритий онлан-курс (МВОК), відкритий освітній ресурс (ВОС), університети Ліги плюща, безперервна освіта.
В статье рассмотрено новое направление электронного обучения - массовые открытые онлайн-курсы, разработанные университетами Лиги плюща и другими элитными университетами по всему миру. Поскольку эти курсы являются бесплатными, речь идет о революционных изменениях в системе высшего образования на глобальном уровне. Наряду с рядом преимуществ, такой способ обучения создает некоторые трудности как студентам, так и преподавателям.
Ключевые слова: электронное обучение, массовый открытый онлан-курс (МООК), открытый образовательный ресурс (ООР), университеты Лиги плюща, непрерывное образование.
This paper gives in-depth understanding about the Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs) from the Ivy League and other elite universities from across the world. As these courses are free, this led to revolutionary changes in higher education on a global scale. Along with benefits, it creates some challemges for students as well as for educators.
Keywords: E-learning, Massive Open Online Course (MOOC), Open Educational Resource (OER), Ivy League universities, continuing education.
Distance education and online education are nothing new in the education industry. However, 10,000s of students and sometimes more than 100,000s from more than 100 countries for each course is a relatively new phenomenon.
What is more interesting is that the Ivy League (Brown University, Columbia University, Cornell University, Dartmouth College, Harvard University, Princeton University, the University of Pennsylvania, and Yale University) and other elite universities from across the US, Canada, UK, China, India etc. are offering these courses.
The term Ivy League has connotations of academic excellence, selectivity in admissions,
and social elitism. As of now, these universities are offering these courses free of charge. Hence, there is a rush from students from across the world to join these courses. The opportunity to get Ivy League education at zero fee is a huge attraction for students across the world.
This is the beginning of a revolution in academia. This is also being called the “Single Most Important Experiment in Higher Education” .
What are the benefits and challenges of such education for both students and educators?
What is the impact on traditional universities? These questions need to be addressed.
2. The aim, object and methods of research
The aim of this research is to reveal the distinctiveness of online education and show the pros and cons of massive open online courses (MOOCs).
The objective of this research is to understand the open online university education.
The subject of research is to review the main features of online education in general and massive open online courses, in particular.
The research methods that were used are induction, deduction, generalization, extrapolation and comparison. A survey was also conducted to collect data from students.
3. Brief history of free online university education
Ten years ago, the idea of free sharing of knowledge on the internet started with the free sharing of video lectures without any assignments and deadlines . In the later years, the idea transformed into free sharing of educational resources, initiated first by the University of Tübingen in Germany and then it became quite common when Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) created OpenCourseWare (OCW) . On the MIT OCW, today we can find lecture notes, assignments, and projects on over 2,100 courses . MIT OCW initiative was replicated by other Ivy League universities such as Stanford and Harvard, by offering free online access to some of their courses and materials.
Yet, a few years ago, the development of self-contained online courses looked utopian. A major barrier to free online education was financial support due to economic decline in 2009. The good thing is that, the forecast for “death deadline” was right and now we are the witness to a unique global experiment by the top-ranked universities across the world. Online education is making great strides and revolutionizing the educational process. As part of having free access to videos, lecture notes etc. a person is able to feel as a real student with almost all the associated activities. A student can start studying at the time of his/her choice, take a break, then come back, and continue with the video lecures at the own discretion.
A major advantage of online learning is the elimination of a physical location. Sharing knowledge freely enables students (residing in different parts of the world) to pursue any course of their choice at any international university that offers online courses.
The educational model offered now sounds like: “Do you like this? Enroll now!” . This recent development in area of distance education is called Massive open online course (MOOC) [4, 5], with it’s main attributes being short-term but largescale participation and open access via the web.
A complete list of free online courses can be found at Online Education Database (OEDb) . For example, Coursera platform (Fig.1)  offers 200 courses from 30 top-ranked universities in USA, Canada, Europe, China and India. Topics include Computer Science, Business, Social Sciences, Mathematics, Humanities, Medicine, Biology, and many others. At present Coursera’s learning community counts more than 1.3 million students . The duration of a course usually varies from 6 to 10 weeks. Each course has anywhere from, 10,000 to 100,000 students enrolled. To teach them face-to-face in a “real university” the professors will need hundreds of years.
4. Distinctiveness of the Massive open online courses: theoretical analysis
Regardless of the availability of distance learning courses including e-learning, the distinctiveness of MOOC need to be studied to understand their educational methods and how they are being further developed. Some early recommendations for online teaching, presenting tools types, examples and instructional uses are given in . Studies determined that courses focused on development of cognitive abilities of the students are the most appropriate for teaching online.
All forms of E-learning (electronically supported learning and teaching) are applied – information and communication systems, mostly based on network learning [11, 12].
However, there is a viewpoint that distance learning tends to copy the so-called traditional educational model and that influences the balance against the distance learning .
The launch of a large number of MOOCs forced the creation of instructional strategies and types of learning activities different from those in traditional learning.
Educational platforms apply similar forms of learning activities, which vary depending
on the course. However, all the courses have video and socialnetworking components (forums, study groups on social networks like Facebook, Google+). Weekly quizzes, design projects or essays, and sometimes a final project or exam provides evaluation of students’ efforts.
According to data given in , three main didactical models are applied to the
The traditional model of education is teacher-oriented and the ‘student-student’
links are comparatively weak there; whereas online educational model is studentoriented
and ‘student-student’ links are strong and communicate less with the professor.
The students give immediate feedback via The Discussion Forums. The students
are also involved in the peer evaluation of course projects. (Fig. 2). The professors’
direct feedback is rather low.
Therefore, the main postulates of massive open online courses can be formulated
Teacher is not at the centre of the classroom anymore.
Opportunites for studying and mentorship are endless.
Student can be a mentor and mentor can be a student.
The analysis of data , made by Coursera “demonstrates very convincingly that online learning methods are, on average as effective as face-to-face learning. Further, hybrid methods, which involve both methods of instruction, and is being offered by our partner universities to many of their on-campus students using our platform, are considerably more effective than either method alone” .
5. Advantages and disadvantages of Massive open online courses
We can define the key advantages to free online courses as:
Convenience: student has the ability to study at any location with access to a
computer and an internet connection, while having busy schedules including work
Flexibility: students learn through a variety of work activities and allow them
to apply different learning styles;
Ivy League Opportunity: Ivy League education is available for free, without restriction,
and made available to anyone interested.
Despite these advantages, some students might experience disadvantages with
these classes. Ability to work with computer and the lack of face-to-face interaction
are viewed as the main down side to free online courses. Individuals with little or no
ability to manage computer files, software, and documents may find these courses
The analysis of the available data [2, 4, 6, 16-24], permits us to separate several
groups of factors reflecting advantages and disadvantages of online educational process:
Institutional factors – related to organization of educational process;
Social factors – related to social issues of educational process;
Technological factors –related to technological issues of educational process;
Economical factors – related to economical issues of educational process;
Personality factors – related to personal issues of participants of educational
Therefore, the main advantages (benefits) and disadvantages (challenges) are represented
separated into the groups reflecting above mentioned factors.
6. Survey results
To understand the student’s attitude to studying MOOCs, a survey was sent tostudents of two courses on two different platforms. They are ‘Technology Entrepreneurship’ course taught on Stanford University’s Venture Lab platform and ‘Introduction to Sustainability’ course taught by faculty from University of Illinois on the Coursera Platform. The amount of respondents was 27; therefore, each vote is equal to 3.7%.
Inspite of the low number of respondents, the results of the survey are rather representative
of the viewpoints of students from across the world. The demographics include students mostly from Europe (51%) (Fig.3a), of different educational levels, but with at least one academic degree (37% with bachelor degree and 44% with master degree) (Fig. 3b). That confirms the higher interest and higher motivation to study short-term massive open online courses for persons who has diploma from traditional universities.
As to the number of courses started, (Fig.4a) about the quarter of the respondents started to study one or two courses and one third of them studies more than three courses. As to the completion, most of the respondents (two thirds) have completed one course. The most active part of respondents (11%) has completed more than three courses (Fig. 4b). Such results can serve the evidence of initial overestimation of personal capabilities, disappointment with studying process and its intermediate result at the initial stage, lack of stimuli to complete the course that usually happens in faceto-face education. As per the data, only about 20% of students enrolled complete the on-line courses .
On the other hand, that result can be linked to the short history of such courses. As for the main reasons to study short-term massive open online courses there are options: two thirds of the respondents selected ‘studying for the sake of studying’: so they enjoy the process of acquiring new knowledge. About 40% of the respondents expect to promote their career; one third of respondents feel lack of knowledge after completion face-to-face education and one fifth of respondents needs in re-training. The respondents also suggested some other options: getting the certificate (one respondent), way of personal improvement, the basis for innovation (one respondent) and implementing personal dream (one respondent). Some persons want
either to refresh knowledge (one reply), or to get new knowledge from the latest sources (two replies). One respondent pointed out that learning English is a prerequisite for all courses.
As the disadvantages go, most of respondents point out the impossibility of personal
interaction with lecturers and students (70% of respondents). In other words, lack of ‘real’ social activity cannot be substituted completely by ‘virtual’ activity (70%) (Fig. 6b). Half of the respondent are concerned by the absence of certificates upon completion the course or their in-equivalence like a ‘real university’ diploma. However, in the eyes of some employers around the world, online certificates are worth almost the same or even more than some university diploma. In Ukraine, such a scenario exits, mostly for the Computer Science field .
Other issues include, low participation in group projects because, it is not a priority, people join and leave projects quickly as there is no commitment.
On a whole, considering the efficiency of online education, the respondents reveal optimistic view on it. One third of the respondents consider it more effective
than face-to-face education and almost half of the respondents think that they are both
equal. 60% of the respondents are completely satisfied with online education, 37% of
respondents are partly satisfied with it and only 4% are unsatisfied with it.
6. Personal experience of the authors in on-line learning.
The authors of this paper graduated from the universities some time ago. On the other hand, we were students and got to know each other through the Technology Entrepreneurship
Class at Stanford University Online. For now, we are enrolled in more than one on-line course and as consequence we cannot but share our personal impressions.
Being an educator (N.L.) I would strictly recommend the persons engaged in face-to-face educational industry to participate in MOOCs. It is my personal opinion that educators
have to be enrolled in relevant courses both as students and as mentors, as it is a free opportunity to learn some new teaching skills, adopt priceless teaching experience from professors of top-universities, to open a dialog and discuss with them. Openness to the whole world, short terms are essential conditions for the flexibility of the course and testing educator’s skills would be interesting and useful for a wide audience as they get fast feedback.
Some students do not like the idea of gamification of education. Things like badges for mandatory posts every week in the Discussion Forum, mandatory voting on Forum posts etc. shifts the focus from education to playing games (P.K.).
The personal experience with free online classes proved to be the challenge student
is seeking. There is a possibility to find classes that matched educational skill level and grow knowledge on specific topics. The ability to attend a free online course offered by an Ivy League school would not have been possible without the online platform (A.R.)
There is no doubt that development of Massive Open Online Courses has a significant impact on the education process across the whole world. The key advantages of it are convenience, flexibility, and opportunity. Now we observe a competition of two different value systems in the educational area i.e. real vs. virtual.
On the other hand, we should not overestimate the significance of that phenomenon. In our opinion, the ‘virtual’ education is not a total substitute for the ‘real’ educational in traditonal universities. There are many branches of science, which are impossible to be taught online (architecture, medicine, etc.). Besides that, ethical issues of student evaluation came up, and there are doubts if student works independently.
Having the whole world as your classmates is definitely overwhelming. Thus, we should not consider it as a kind of religion and not create the illusion of getting the deep knowledge within a few weeks. Before making the decision to enroll in any online distance-learning program, a person must have clear evidence why he (or she) is joining the course. Otherwise, they will be confused about the work requirements and fall behind. The MOOCs are best for self-driven students with a high motivation to learn.
Most of the researchers prove that, the future belongs to blended learning when methods of face-to-face and online education coexist. We would find difficult to quarrel with this statement. As a separate learning method, MOOCs can exist for prediploma (to get a basic overview for a particular course) and post-diploma education (to retrain/refresh/broaden knowledge). MOOCs can be an integral part of continuing education process.
1. Weissmann, J., 2012. The Single Most Important Experiment in Higher Education. [Online] The Atlantic, 18 July 2012, Available at: <http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/07/the-single-most-importantexperiment-in-higher-education/259953> [Accessed 5 October 2012].
2. Parry M., 2009. Open Courses: Free, but Oh, So Costly. [Online] 11 October. Available at: <The Chronicle of Higher Education. http://chronicle.com/article/Free-Online-Courses-at-a-Very/48777/> [Accessed 5 October 2012].
3. MIT Open Course Ware [online] Available at: <http://ocw.mit.edu/courses>[Accessed 6 October 2012].
4. Massive open online course (MOOC), 2012. [online] Available at:<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massive_open_online_course> [Accessed 6 October 2012].
5. Welcome to mooc.ca, 2012. [online] Available at <http://mooc.ca/> [Accessed 8 October 2012].
6. How Coursera, A Free Online Education Service, Will School Us All
7. Online Education Database (OEDb), 2012. [online] Available at:<http://oedb.org/about/> [Accessed 7 October 2012].
8. Coursera, 2012. [online] Available at <https://www.coursera.org> [Accessed 7 October 2012].
9. Empson, R. 2012. Your Online Ivy: Coursera Now Hosts 200 Courses from 33 Schools & Reaches 1.3M Students [online] 19 September. Available at: <http://techcrunch.com/2012/09/19/your-online-ivy-coursera-now-hosts-200-coursesfrom-33-schools-and-reaches-1-3m-students> [Accessed 8 October 2012].
10. Zhu, E., Payette, P., DeZure, D. 2003. An Introduction to Teaching Online [online]. CRLT Occasional Papers. Center for Research on Learning and Teaching – University of Michigan. Available at:<http://www.crlt.umich.edu/sites/default/files/resource_files/CRLT_no18.pdf> [Accessed 7 October 2012].
11. E-learning [online] Available at: <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-learning>[Accessed 6 October 2012].
12. Kamsin, A., 2005. Is E-Learning the Solution and Substitute for Conventional Learning? International Journal of The Computer, the Internet and Management Vol.
13.No.3 (2005) pp. 79-89. [online] Available at:<http://www.journal.au.edu/ijcim/2005/sep05/ijcimv13n3_article7.pdf> [Accessed 9 October 2012].
13. Distance Learning versus Brick and Mortar. An analysis at the university level. [online] Available at: <http://www.silentpc.org/university/distance.php> [Accessed 9 October 2012].
14. Instructional Strategies for Online Courses, 2012. [online] Available at:http://www.ion.uillinois.edu/resources/tutorials/pedagogy/instructionalstrategies.asp#
LEARNING CONTRACTS [Accessed 6 October 2012].
15. Didactical models in (e-)Learning [online] Available at:<http://www.leerbeleving.nl/wbts/1/didactical_models.html> [Accessed 4 October 2012].
16. Online Distance Learning Courses for International Students, 2012. [Online] 22 May. Available at: <http://scholarship-positions.com/blog/online-distancelearning-courses-for-international-student-2/201205> [Accessed 4 October 2012].
17. Smialek J., 2012. Free Online Classes Are Little Help in Job Hunt [online] 10 August. Available at: <http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2012-08-10/freeonline-classes-are-little-help-in-job-hunt> [Accessed 9 October 2012].
18. Pedagogy, 2012. [online] Available at:<https://www.coursera.org/about/pedagogy> [Accessed 5 October 2012].
19. Littlefield, J. 10 Reasons to Choose Online Education [online] Available at:<http://distancelearn.about.com/od/distancelearning101/tp/10-Reasons-to-Choose-
Online-Education.htm> [Accessed 7 October 2012].
20. McKendrick, J. 2011. Education disrupted MIT to offer free, online courses to all. [online] Available at: <http://www.smartplanet.com/blog/businessbrains/education-disrupted-mit-to-offer-free-online-courses-to-all/20912> [Accessed 6 October 2012].
21. Kuther, T. What Are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Online Education for Graduate Study [online] Available at:http://gradschool.about.com/od/distanceeducation/f/onlineadv.htm [Accessed 7 October 2012].
22. James, G. Advantages and disadvantages of online learning. [online] Available at: http://www.leerbeleving.nl/wbts/1/addis.pdf [Accessed 8 October 2012].
23. Harvard, J. Advantages and Disadvantages of Online Education [online] Available at:
nd_disadvantages_of_online_education.html [Accessed 8 October 2012].
24. Straus, R.R., 2012. Study at Princeton without paying a penny: How you could study courses from world-class universities for free [online] 21 September, Available at: <http://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/studentfinance/article-2206167/Coursera-How-study-courses-world-class-universities-free.html> [Accessed 6 October 2012].
25. Evaluation of Evidence-Based Practices in Online Learning: A Meta-Analysis and Review of Online Learning Studies 2010. U.S. Department of Education. Office of Planning, Evaluation, and Policy Development. Policy and Program Studies Service. 2010, September. - 94 p.
26. Богданович Е. Глобальный Гарвард. Как учиться в самых престижных университетах мира без денег и личного присутствия// Корреспондент. – 2012. №33. // Режим доступа: http://korrespondent.net/business/career/1388196-korrespondent-globalnyj-garvard-kak-uchitsya-v-samyh-prestizhnyh-universitetahmira-bez-deneg-i-lich.